« Timelines of History | Main | What If German and Austrian Monarchies Were Retained? »

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

S.M. Stirling

Nonsense.

To begin with, the conventional bombing was just as destructive as the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings; 100,000 people died in a single night during the firestorm raids on Tokyo.

In WWII, indiscriminate bombardment of civilians from the air was simply generally accepted. For that matter, we killed 30,000 -French- civilians in the month before D-Day (about 1000 a day) in our attacks on the French railway network.

And even -with- the nuclear bombs, fanatical Army officers were trying to take the Emperor prisoner to prevent a surrender. Some elements of the Japanese leadership wanted to surrender; plenty of others wanted to fight to the last teenage girl with a bamboo spear, and the population was prepared to obey.

The comments to this entry are closed.