Slender Threads: 'What If's' of History. Almosts and Alternatives

“On what slender threads do life and fortune hang.” ― Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo

  • Home
  • Archives
  • Profile
  • Subscribe

What If Crusades Failed?

Ian Gould asks on Facebook: "What if the First Crusade (1096-99) ended in disaster at the Battle of Dorylaeum (where the Seljuks attacked one half of a divided Crusader army only to have the other half arrive during the battle) or at the siege of Antioch (the Crusaders took the city after an extended siege but then found themselves in turn besieged by Turkish reinforcements and were only saved the opportune arrival of another contingent of Crusaders).

"After the disaster of the earlier's People's Crusade might Europeans have simply given up on the idea of retaking Jerusalem?

"Would no fourth Crusade have meant the Byzantine Empire survived?

"Would the Reconquest of Spain and the conversion of the pagans of north eastern Europe have proceeded faster?

"Would the Age of Discovery have started sooner?"

Discussion on Facebook. 

Gavin Bowen writes: "The Fifth Crusade was a failed attempt by Christian crusaders to invade Egypt and reestablish Christian control in the Holy Land. After the Crusaders captured the port of Damietta the Egyptian Sultan offered the Crusaders control of the Holy land for return of the city. This offer was refused and the Crusaders were ultimately encircled and destroyed while attempting to march south and capture Cairo. What would have happened if they had succeeded in capturing Cairo and establishing a Christian state in Egypt? Could they have held onto it or would it have fallen like the Crusader States in the Levant?" Discussion on Facebook. 

 

Related articles
Brief Book Review: In God's Path: The Arab Conquests and the Creation of an Islamic Empire by Robert G. Hoyland
In the Shadows of Hagia Sophia.

Posted at 03:58 PM in 1000s | Permalink | Comments (0)

Reblog (0)

Categories

  • 1000s
  • 1200s
  • 1300s
  • 1400s
  • 1500s
  • 1600s
  • 1700s
  • 1800s
  • 1900s
  • 1910s
  • 1920s
  • 1930s
  • 1940s
  • 1950s
  • 1960s
  • 1970s
  • 1980s
  • 1990s
  • 2000s
  • 2010s
  • 300s
  • 400s
  • 700s
  • Africa
  • Al Gore
  • Alternative History Sites
  • American Independence
  • American Military History: What If's
  • Asia
  • Aztecs
  • BC
  • Biography
  • Black Swans
  • Books
  • Bush
  • Carter
  • Causality
  • Chaos Theory
  • China
  • Civil War
  • Cleopatra's Nose
  • Clintons
  • Cold War
  • Cure for Hyperpartisanship
  • Destiny
  • Disasters
  • Divine Providence
  • Economics
  • Eisenhower
  • Europe
  • Fate
  • FDR
  • Genre
  • Great Men Theory
  • Henry VIII
  • History's Losers
  • Inventions
  • Iraq
  • Israel
  • Kennedys
  • Korea
  • LBJ
  • Lessons & Courses
  • Lincoln
  • Media
  • Mexico
  • MLKing
  • Napoleon
  • Necessity of Wars?
  • Nixon
  • Obama
  • Preface
  • Reader Comments
  • Reagan
  • Richard III
  • Roman Empire
  • Russia
  • Saddam Hussein
  • Table of Contents
  • Teleology
  • Testimonials
  • Texas
  • Timelines
  • TR
  • Truman
  • Videos
  • Vietnam
  • Why Should We Care About What Ifs?
  • Wilson
  • WWI
  • WWII
Buie Knife
Buie Knife
11 Following
70 Followers
Bea Anil Dash cheripickr Geri Henderson Ed Cone Helms Jackson The Typepad Team Ginevra Frank Gruber malcolmgladwell btrott

Recent Comments

  • S.M. Stirling on Was Nuking of Nagasaki, Japan Necessary?
  • S.M. Stirling on If Not for Joan of Arc's Victory at Orleans, France Would Have Become English Vassal
  • Michael FitzGerald on Overdone Alternative Histories
  • Winston on Terrorism in Europe Grew Out of French and British Colonialism
  • Winston on Terrorism in Europe Grew Out of French and British Colonialism
  • Alexandra Hopkins on Election Patterns Suggest US Is Ripe for One-Term Presidency After 2016
  • Slender Threads: 'What If's' of History
  • Powered by Typepad